Yes, it can. Whether your student house needs a licence does not depend only on the mandatory HMO regime. There are three separate licensing schemes under the Housing Act 2004, and a property can fall outside the mandatory scheme but still be caught by one of the two discretionary local schemes.
The three licensing regimes
Mandatory HMO licensing applies across all of England to any house in multiple occupation that meets the standard test (broadly, occupied by five or more people forming two or more households who share basic amenities such as a kitchen or bathroom). This is national and does not depend on where the property is.
Additional HMO licensing is a discretionary scheme that an individual council can introduce for a designated area. It extends licensing to HMOs that do not meet the mandatory threshold, for example a house shared by three or four unrelated students who share facilities. Many university towns and cities operate additional licensing precisely because of the concentration of smaller student HMOs. So a three or four person student share that escapes mandatory licensing may still need a licence if the council has designated the area for additional licensing.
Selective licensing is a discretionary scheme that can require a licence for privately rented dwellings that are not HMOs at all, within a designated area. It typically targets areas with low housing demand, significant anti-social behaviour, poor property conditions or high migration. If your student house happens to be a single household, or otherwise is not an HMO, it could still need a licence under a selective licensing designation.
Why the mandatory test is not the whole picture
The point of the additional and selective schemes is that Parliament gave councils power to extend licensing beyond the national mandatory baseline. A property being outside the mandatory scheme tells you nothing about whether the local council has chosen to designate the area for additional or selective licensing. These designations are local, they vary street by street in some cities, and they change over time as schemes are introduced, renewed or allowed to lapse (designations usually run for up to five years).
How to check what applies to your property
1. Identify the exact status of the house: how many occupiers, how many separate households, and whether they share amenities. This determines whether it is an HMO at all, and if so whether it is mandatory or only potentially caught by additional licensing.
2. Check the specific council for the property’s address. Licensing is administered by the local housing authority, and each publishes its current designations. Search the council website for HMO licensing, additional licensing and selective licensing, and check whether your street or ward falls within a designated area. Many councils have an online postcode checker.
3. Confirm the dates of any designation. Schemes have start and end dates, and a new scheme may replace an expiring one, so verify that any designation is currently in force for the relevant period.
Consequences of getting it wrong
Operating a licensable property without a licence is a criminal offence and can attract a substantial fine or a financial penalty of up to thirty thousand pounds imposed by the council instead of prosecution. It also exposes the landlord to a rent repayment order, under which a tribunal can order repayment of up to twelve months’ rent to the tenants or to the council where housing benefit or universal credit was paid. A landlord who does not have a required licence is also generally unable to serve a valid section 21 no fault possession notice while the property remains unlicensed. These consequences apply equally whether the missing licence is mandatory, additional or selective.
Practical points
If you are the tenant rather than the landlord, it is still worth checking, because an unlicensed but licensable property may give you a rent repayment claim and affects the landlord’s ability to evict you. If you are the landlord or managing agent, do not assume that falling below the five person mandatory threshold means no licence is needed. The safest step is a direct written enquiry to the local housing authority confirming, for that specific address and letting arrangement, whether mandatory, additional or selective licensing applies, and keeping the reply on file.
Key missing facts
To give a definitive answer for your house I would need the full property address or at least the council area, the number of occupiers and how many separate households they form, whether they share kitchen or bathroom facilities, and whether the building is a single house or converted into flats. These determine both whether it is an HMO and which, if any, of the three schemes bites.
This answer draws on broad legal knowledge and checks current law, guidance and procedure against relevant sources.
Houses in multiple occupation and residential property licensing reform: guidance for local housing authorities - GOV.UKgov.ukHouse in multiple occupation licencegov.ukThe Housing Act 2004: Licensing of Houses in Multiple Occupation and Selective Licensing of Other Residential Accommodation (England) General Approval 2024 - GOV.UKgov.ukHousing Act 2004legislation.gov.ukKNOW WHERE YOU STAND
Ready to stop guessing?
The above is just an example answer. Sign up now to get personalised guidance and ask follow-up questions based on your own situation. Bring your legal issue, your contract, or your question. Lawyer Destroyer gives you clear, practical guidance so you can move forward with confidence.